Benchmarking Ad Spend: Tools CFOs Can Trust

Marketing teams report. Finance teams reconcile. But when the data doesn’t line up, the problem often lies in the tools and not the teams.

Across paid advertising, CFOs need to assess ROI, compare cost efficiency, and hold platforms accountable for results. But most available benchmarks come from the very platforms charging the spend and their numbers often exclude the waste, risk, and anomalies that quietly eat into margins.

That’s where audit-grade benchmarking becomes indispensable.

‍

Why Traditional Analytics Tools Fall Short

Most analytics dashboards, whether native (like Google Ads, Meta Business Manager) or 3rd-party, use sampled or aggregated data. They rarely show per-click detail, and often accept attribution and conversion data at face value. For CFOs, that means you’re building models on unverified inputs.

Analytics tools don’t ask:

• Was that a real user or a bot?
• Did that click come from a target market, or out-of-geo?
• Was that conversion a genuine lead or MFA (Made-for-Ads) spam?
• Are refunds possible if platforms overcharged for invalid traffic?

They just show spend, clicks, and results, no matter the integrity of the underlying data.

‍

Why Audit Benchmarks Matter

Instead of relying on platform-supplied metrics, audit-based benchmarks provide CFOs with independent, per-click validation. Based on over 100 recent audits by Vaudit, we’ve uncovered a consistent pattern of hidden cost erosion across major ad platforms.

Here’s what we’ve seen across 105 clients:

• 13.2% of total ad spend, on average, is invalid. That includes bot clicks, fake impressions, MFA traffic, and more. In some high-risk accounts, this number has climbed to over 46%.
  
  
• Geo Violations - where ads are shown in regions they shouldn’t be (like US-only campaigns serving Asia),  occur in 4.7% of spend, and up to 19% for some accounts.
  
  
• Pre-bill cost controls (like Vaudit’s User Exclusions and Negative Audiences) have helped reduce 8.5% of spend on average before it even hits the bill, up to 21% in certain environments.
  
  
• Post-bill refund claims (for mischarged or misattributed traffic) return 5.3% in median value, with some clients recovering as much as 18%.
  
  
• AI-driven bid optimizations across campaigns are showing a consistent 3.1% reduction in spend while maintaining conversion volume, not by pausing campaigns, but by suppressing spend in segments with invalid or underperforming traffic.

All of this is based on real audit data, not modeled or estimated by platforms.

‍

From Marketing Narrative to Financial Reality

For CFOs, the goal isn’t just to understand performance, it’s to enforce accountability.

When finance leaders rely solely on marketing dashboards, they’re forced to accept assumptions they can’t verify. But with an audit-backed benchmark approach, CFOs can:

• Validate attribution logic across platforms, filtering for clean clicks only.
• Measure campaign integrity, not just delivery.
• Quantify recoverable waste and drive refund processes with evidence.
• Align budgets with validated returns, improving P&L clarity.
• Set performance expectations across departments using real, defensible data.

‍

Why Audit Benchmarks > Analytics Benchmarks

Let’s break down the core differences between platform analytics and Vaudit’s audit-based benchmarking:

• Data integrity: Analytics tools use sampled data. Audits use every click.
• Attribution accuracy: Platforms self-attribute. Audits verify against traffic validity.
• Visibility: Dashboards show you totals. Audits expose misfires, outliers, and risks.
• Financial rigor: Analytics support optimization. Audits support accountability.

In short: platforms report performance, but only audits can verify truth.

‍

What CFOs Can Do Now

Whether your organization is spending $100K or $10M+ on paid ads, benchmarking shouldn’t be guesswork. And it shouldn’t be outsourced entirely to your media agency or ad platforms.

If you’re a CFO who wants:

• Clarity on what portion of your ad budget is truly delivering ROI
• Independent validation of your reported marketing results
• Defensible refund claims backed by forensic-grade logs
• Real savings before the invoice hits your desk

Then Vaudit’s audit benchmark suite gives you exactly that, without relying on media buyer promises or black-box dashboards.

‍

Ready to See Where Your Ad Spend Doesn’t Add Up?

With Vaudit, you can benchmark your current ad spend against our COSO-grade standards across Google, Meta, and mobile ad platforms.

You’ll receive:

• A complete breakdown of invalid traffic rates
• Real-time flagging of geo and device violations
• A report on refundable charges
• Projected savings based on real-time enforcement
• And a 2X performance guarantee - if you don’t save double our cost, you don’t pay.

No black boxes. No assumptions. Just truth in every click.

Start your audit now with Vaudit! 

‍